You know what completely astounds me? The fact that with the Adamas (particularly the junior of the pair) that the human race ever made it anywhere. Sure, Admiral Cain was a bit of a bitch, but I agree with Starbuck: they were much better off with her than without her. Adama as a person is a person I admire greatly, but as a leader I question his decisions quite a lot. This becomes incredibly and glaringly obvious to me during the Exodus from New Caprica.
If, during previous events, the Pegasus lasted for awhile (and even managed to destroy one) against THREE battlestars and warp out without help from the Galactica, why the holy hell would it be impossible to take out two Cylon battlestars with the Pegasus and the Galactica? Don’t whine at me about there being four and being unstaffed — there are a million ways they could have taken out the first two before they went after the second two which warped in.
Not only that, but Sharon became Adama’s closest friend and confidant during those months that Saul Tigh was away. It’s already been proven that the Cylons will blindly take on ships which appear to be fleet when they are carrying a Cylon transponder — why not have your now FRIENDLY cylon build you transponders? They already had a third transponder model she would have worked from.
To top it off, they have nukes and the Cylon base stars are incredibly fragile; the battlestars the humans made had huge amounts of plating set to deal with nuclear attack, while the base stars, when hit in the middle of their axis, became almost instantly useless and blew up.
Now, about the retarded statement that they were understaffed: they didn’t have to be understaffed! After making connection, Sharon could have jumped repeatedly in and out of atmo, landed, and taken pilots back with her. The fact that the Cylons had no idea they had even made radio contact until Tigh’s wife gave them the map makes it obvious that they’re pretty goddamn good at sneaking around the Cylons. Why the fuck wouldn’t they get their needed military crew out BEFORE launching an attack?! Oh, it’s risky? Right, and the fact that Adama went into the battle with everyone believing it was a suicide mission ANYWAY made it impossible.
Honestly, if this whole bullshit went down with Cain still there, after the incredible warpath she’d torn before she was put down by the pettiness of the fleet and Gaius Baltar’s stupidity, then I’m pretty goddamn sure that the Pegasus could have dealt with three of those basestars and left one to Galatica.
Hell, if Galactica and her crew had stop being such pissants about fighting and, as Adama said, turned around and punched the schoolyard bully in the face, I’m pretty sure they’d have been much better off for it a long time ago. Obviously the Galactica is made of sterner stuff (according to the writers) than Pegasus based on the amount of abuse she takes; the Pegasus bit it after much less than you see the Galactica take, despite having just as wastrel a crew. Why she can take that much abuse so many times in the series when the writers want to make really cinematic space battles with her and then can’t handle one or two base stars is beyond me.
Personally, if I were Adama, I’d have given up my men — as much as I cared for them — and followed Cain as the military decorum required. Anyone who can turn on their lover because they’re the enemy is exactly the type of leader you need in a military setting when the stakes you’re playing for is the human race.
I genuinely believe that Cain would not have tossed the entire fleet, either. She’s not an idiot. In all the flashbacks and specials it doesn’t show her with a gigantic fleet like the Galactica was used to dealing with, it showed her taking on three or four ships at a time during the start of a war campaign. Honestly, I think that a lot of what she did was despicable, but it saved her and her crew and eventually because of that saved Adama’s civilian fleet from the mess they made themselves on New Caprica. Without those brutal decisions, the show would have ended pretty prematurely.
Additional to that is the fact that I don’t think she’s a completely unchanging character. Obviously when she sensed the chance that she and Adama working together would improve military chances, she softened her approach and allowed him to live despite the fact that his behaviour against a superior officer was treasonous; nothing she did was actually against colonial law. Throughout the show the writers bang our heads against the wall about the goodness of Adama and Roselyn in trying to uphold colonial law (and even when they make mistakes they’re still good), yet as soon as a character comes in who does this same thing unflinchingly, because she does it to characters we like, the writers seem inspired to treat her as though she’s less than human. They never bother to give poor Cain much of a chance to show her real personality beneath the pain of what she’s suffered in the war, yet even a majority of the Cylons are given more humane treatment.
How does that make any sense?
Thankfully the show has a lot of other really amazing moments of struggle, real struggle, not just TV struggle. Making us appreciate suicide bombing, the president’s decision to make a woman’s choice illegal, or especially Baltar’s trial and the outcome — all of these are wonderful. It’s just too bad that the character most like reality was the one most vilified — Pegasus reaching actual potential was a real Admiral like Cain would have been an astoundingly impressive storyline. I think it would have been even better if the character choices involved in Cain and her work made the world even less black and white. The story really tries to be truly very gray as it goes along, but it could have been pushed a hell of a lot more and still been excellent. I’d especially love to have seen Cain react to things like the Cylon alliance (by that point more of her backstory of her lesbian relationship with the 6 would have been revealed), or how she would galvanize people’s opinions during things like the election. She’s no saint, but I’m pretty sure that with the proper writing she could have been goddamn amazing.
Let’s not even get into how ridiculous it is to give a character depth only through a special and never mention her inhumane treatment of a prisoner stemming not just from hatred at the genocide of the human race, but the betrayal of a lover.
(I love Battlestar Galactica, but still… that part bugs me a lot.)